Go Auto Insurance

Auto Insurance

Discover How Credit History Affects Car Insurance

By admin · Updated · 8 min read

In most part of the United States, you might expect car insurance to depend on how you drive, but it also depends on how you handle money. Insurers use information from your credit report to help set what you pay, and two drivers with identical records can be quoted very different prices because of it. This article explains how that works, which states don’t allow it, what you can check, and what you can do to improve your position.

  • In most states in the US, insurers use a special number called a credit-based insurance score, which is built from your credit report.
  • It is not the same as the credit score you see in your banking app.
  • A handful of states ban or limit the practice, so the rules depend on where you live.
  • Getting a quote normally does not hurt your credit score.
  • You can improve your position by checking your reports, fixing errors, building good habits and comparing insurers.

What is a credit-based insurance score?

When a lender decides whether to give you a loan, it looks at your credit score. An insurer is trying to answer a different question: how likely are you to file claims? To help predict that, many insurers calculate a credit-based insurance score, often shortened to an insurance score.

Both numbers draw on the same raw material, your credit report. That includes things like your payment history, how much debt you carry, how long you have had credit, and how much credit you have available. But the formulas and the purposes differ. This is why you can have a good credit score and a different-looking insurance score, and why you usually can’t look up your insurance score yourself. Insurers typically don’t share it directly with consumers.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the organization of state insurance regulators, explains that an insurance score is not the same as a regular credit score. It also notes that information that is not on your credit report, including race, color and national origin, cannot be part of the score.

Why insurers use credit information

Insurers say the reason is simple: in their data, people with certain credit patterns file claims more often. An Insurify analysis, for example, notes that drivers with better credit have on average been less likely to file car insurance claims. Because of that pattern, the NAIC reports that about 95% of auto insurers use credit-based insurance scores in the states where the practice is allowed.

That is the industry’s case. Critics see it differently. Consumer advocates argue that credit history says nothing about how safely a person drives, and that it can penalize people for financial setbacks like illness or job loss, and may fall hardest on lower-income households. This debate is the reason several states have restricted the practice, and why more may follow. Reasonable people disagree here, and the rules you face depend on your state.

Which states don’t allow it?

Insurance is regulated mainly by states, so the rules are not the same everywhere. Based on the sources we reviewed:

  • California, Hawaii and Massachusetts are generally described as prohibiting the use of credit information in setting car insurance rates.
  • Michigan is listed by some sources as banning or significantly restricting it.
  • Maryland, Oregon and Utah are described as having certain limits on how credit can be used.

Sources do not agree on every detail, and lawmakers in other states, including New York, have considered new limits. Rules can change, and they can differ by type of insurance. To be sure about your state, check your state Department of Insurance website or call them.

Even where credit is allowed, insurers generally cannot treat it as the only reason to raise your price. Many states also require an insurer to tell you when credit information played a part in a decision that went against you, such as higher pricing or a denial. If you get a notice like that, read it, because it tells you which credit bureau supplied the data.

Does getting a quote hurt your credit?

Usually not. Insurers normally check your credit with what is called a soft inquiry, which does not lower your credit score, unlike a hard inquiry that happens when you apply for a loan or credit card. This is why you can compare several quotes without damaging your credit. Insurify notes that this applies in most cases, though some states restrict credit checks altogether. If you are unsure, ask the company before you give permission.

How much does it matter?

It depends. Different insurers weigh credit differently, and some give it more influence than others. The same driver might get a far higher quote from one company than another for this reason. That is a good argument for comparing several insurers, rather than assuming one company’s price reflects the whole market.

What we can say with confidence is that credit information is one factor among many. Your driving record, claims history, vehicle, mileage and location also count, and in most places they count a lot.

[Optional but recommended: add a short paragraph from your own experience here, for example how you or someone you know compared quotes after a change in credit, in your own words. Only include things that are true.]

What you can do to improve your position

1. Check your credit reports for errors

You are entitled to free copies of your credit reports from the three main credit bureaus through the official site, AnnualCreditReport.com. Look for accounts you don’t recognize, wrong late-payment marks, balances that are not yours, or debts listed twice. Mistakes are more common than most people expect, and they can drag your numbers down.

2. Dispute anything that is wrong

If you find an error, dispute it in writing with the credit bureau and keep copies of everything. Once an error is corrected, ask your insurer whether they can recheck your credit and reprice your policy.

3. Pay on time, every time

Payment history is one of the most important parts of a credit report. Set up reminders or automatic payments for at least the minimum due, so a busy month doesn’t turn into a late mark.

4. Keep balances low

High balances compared with your limits can hurt your credit. Paying down cards, where you can, helps over time.

5. Be careful with new credit and old accounts

Applying for several new accounts in a short time can lower your score temporarily. Closing a long-standing account can shorten your credit history and reduce your available credit, so think before you do it.

6. Ask your insurer to look again

At renewal, ask whether the company can re-run your credit if your situation has improved. Not every insurer does this automatically, so it is worth asking. If you went through a hard time such as job loss, a serious illness or a divorce, ask whether the insurer or your state allows an exception. Some do.

7. Compare quotes from several insurers

Because companies weigh credit differently, shopping around can matter more when your credit is not perfect. Ask for the same coverage and deductible from each so the quotes are comparable, and include smaller and regional insurers and an independent agent.

8. Beware of anyone promising to fix your insurance score

Companies that charge fees to repair your credit or boost your insurance score often overpromise. Free steps, like checking your reports and disputing mistakes, are the ones that count.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Assuming your credit score is your insurance score. They are related but different.
  • Worrying that quotes will hurt your credit. Normally they won’t.
  • Taking the first quote you get. Prices vary widely between insurers.
  • Skipping your credit reports. Errors are easy to fix and can cost you real money.

Frequently asked questions

Can an insurer cancel my policy or raise my rate because of bad credit? In states where credit use is allowed, insurers can consider it, but the rules limit how. Many states require notice when credit played a role in an adverse decision. Contact your state insurance department if you think the rules weren’t followed.

Can I see my insurance score? Usually not. Insurers normally don’t make it available to consumers. You can check the credit reports it is based on.

Will paying off debt lower my car insurance quickly? It may help over time, but changes don’t always show up immediately. You may only see the effect at your next renewal, or when you ask your insurer to re-check.

I live in a state that bans credit-based pricing. Does any of this apply? Not for setting your car insurance rate. Your driving record, vehicle and location will matter more. Credit habits still matter for loans and other parts of life.

Sources and further reading

  • NAIC, Credit-Based Insurance Scores: https://content.naic.org/insurance-topics/credit-based-insurance-scores
  • NAIC, government affairs brief on insurance credit scores (2019): https://content.naic.org/sites/default/files/government-affairs-brief-credit-insurance-scores.pdf
  • Insurify, Do online insurance quotes affect your credit score?: https://insurify.com/car-insurance/knowledge/do-online-insurance-quotes-affect-credit-score/
  • Insurify, New York may limit use of credit info for car insurance ratings: https://nextjs.insurify.com/car-insurance/news/ny-may-ban-use-of-credit-info-for-car-insurance-rating
  • Insurance News Net, The credit score your insurer uses isn’t your FICO: https://insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/the-credit-score-your-insurer-uses-isnt-your-fico
  • Insurance Information Institute, Background on insurance scoring: https://www.iii.org/article/background-on-insurance-scoring
  • Your state’s Department of Insurance, for the rules where you live.

State rules and industry practices change, and sources differ on some details. Check your state’s current rules before relying on anything above.

This article is general information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Policies, prices and rules vary by insurer and location, so confirm details with your insurer or a licensed agent. See our editorial policy.